Archeologists of the Eastern Mediterranean have noted that Mycenaean civilization GMAT Critical Reasoning

Question: Archeologists of the Eastern Mediterranean have noted that Mycenaean civilization, the Bronze-Age culture that was the leading military and economic power in Greece from approximately 1,600 to 1,100 BCE, went into a sharp decline at around the same time that archeological evidence begins to appear in Greece for another culture, known as the "Sea People." This timing, combined with the evidence of fire damage observed in Mycenaean sites at around 1,100, suggests to many archeologists that the Sea People invaded Greece at this time and conquered the Mycenaeans through force of arms.

Which of the following theories provides the most plausible alternative explanation for the archeological evidence cited above?

  1. Powerful earthquakes in the eastern Mediterranean in around 1,100 BCE inflicted severe damage on Mycenaean cities and weakened them to the point that they could not prevent the Sea People from settling in Greece.
  2. An epidemic of typhus that struck the eastern Mediterranean in around 1,100 BCE severely depopulated Greece and the surrounding area.
  3. The Sea People were not invaders, but rather immigrants who intermarried with the Mycenaeans and became part of their civilization.
  4. A severe drought that hit Greece in around 1,100 BCE made the peninsula uninhabitable, forcing the Mycenaeans to leave Greece for Asia Minor.
  5. The "Sea People" were actually the Phoenicians, an advanced trading civilization that developed in the region that is now known as Syria.


Explanation
:

Given that the Bronze-Age Mycenaean civilization, which ruled Greece from 1,600 to 1,100 BCE, went into a sharp decline around the same time that the "Sea People" culture began to appear in Greece. Many archaeologists believe the Sea People invaded Greece around 1,100 and subjugated the Mycenaeans by force.

Let's approach the answer choices.

A: Correct
It is the correct choice. This theory suggests that the decline of the Mycenaean civilization and the appearance of the Sea People can be attributed to the destructive impact of powerful earthquakes. The earthquakes would have caused significant damage to Mycenaean cities, weakening their military and economic power. This vulnerability may have allowed the Sea People to settle in Greece without necessarily involving a violent invasion or conquest.

B: Incorrect
It is an incorrect choice. If there was indeed a widespread epidemic of typhus in the eastern Mediterranean around 1100 BCE, it could have caused significant population decline in Greece and the surrounding regions. A severe depopulation could have led to a decline in the Mycenaean civilization without the need for external invaders like the Sea People.

C: Incorrect
It is an incorrect answer. This theory does not directly address the evidence of fire damage in Mycenaean sites, it provides an alternative perspective that challenges the assumption of a military invasion by the Sea People.

D: Incorrect
It is an incorrect answer. This scenario implies that the decline of the Mycenaean civilization and the appearance of the Sea People were not due to an invasion but rather a consequence of environmental factors.

E: Incorrect
It is an incorrect choice. The identity of the Sea People and their specific role in the decline of the Mycenaean civilization are still subject to ongoing research and debate among historians and archaeologists. Therefore, while option E presents a plausible alternative explanation, it should be considered alongside other theories and requires further evidence for confirmation.

“Archeologists of the Eastern Mediterranean have noted that Mycenaean civilization” – is a GMAT Critical question. To answer the question, a candidate can either find a piece of evidence that would weaken the argument or have logical flaws in the argument. GMAT critical reasoning tests the logical and analytical skills of the candidates. This topic requires candidates to find the argument's strengths and weaknesses or the logical flaw in the argument. The GMAT CR section contains 10 -13 GMAT critical reasoning questions out of 36 GMAT verbal questions.

Suggested GMAT Critical Reasoning Questions

Comments


No Comments To Show