Consumer: A New Law Requires All Cigarette Packaging To Display a Health Warning GMAT Critical Reasoning

Question: Consumer: a new law requires all cigarette packaging to display a health warning, disturbing pictures of smoke related diseases, and no logos. this law will not affect smoking habit of most people who smoke cigarette regularly, since most of these people rarely look at the packaging when they take out a cigarette.

The conclusion of consumers argument follows logically if which of the following is assumed ?

(A) If implementing certain regulations on packaging of cigarette would affect the smoking habits of those who smoke regularly, those regulations should be implemented
(B) If those who regularly smoke cigarette look at a disturbing pictures of smoking related diseases frequently, it is likely to affect their smoking habits.
(C) Almost all people who regularly smoke cigarette are already familiar with the risks that smoking poses to their health.
(D) The new packaging can not affect the smoking habits of the people who regularly smoke cigarette unless they frequently look at the packaging when taking out cigarettes.
(E) Most people who regularly smoke cigarettes would be unable to describe the log of their unusual brand of cigarette if asked to do so.

Explanation

Given that, Consumer: The new law requires all cigarette packages to carry a health warning, disturbing images of smoking-related diseases, and no logos. this law does not affect the smoking habits of most people who smoke cigarettes regularly because most of them rarely look at the package when they take out a cigarette.

Let's approach the answer choices.

A: Incorrect
This assumption doesn't address the specific claim that the argument is making about the packaging not affecting the smoking habits of regular smokers who don't look at the packaging. It introduces a different ethical or policy perspective.

B: Incorrect
This option assumes a correlation between looking at disturbing pictures and its impact on smoking habits. However, the argument's conclusion is based on the assumption that regular smokers don't look at the packaging, so this option doesn't address the key point.

C: Incorrect
While this option discusses familiarity with the health risks of smoking, it doesn't address the issue of whether the new packaging affects their smoking habits or whether they look at the packaging.

D: Correct
This assumption is necessary because the argument is based on the premise that most regular smokers rarely look at the packaging when taking out a cigarette. If the new packaging can affect their smoking habits even without looking at it, the conclusion of the argument could be invalidated. Therefore, option (D) is the correct assumption that makes the conclusion logically follow.

E: Incorrect
This option is unrelated to the argument's conclusion about the effect of the new packaging on smoking habits. It doesn't address the premise that regular smokers don't look at the packaging.

“Consumer: a new law requires all cigarette packaging to display a health warningl”– is a GMAT Critical question. To answer the question, a candidate can either find a piece of evidence that would weaken the argument or have logical flaws in the argument. GMAT critical reasoning tests the logical and analytical skills of the candidates. This topic requires candidates to find the argument's strengths and weaknesses or the logical flaw in the argument. The GMAT CR section contains 10 -13 GMAT critical reasoning questions out of 36 GMAT verbal questions.

Suggested GMAT Critical Reasoning Questions

Comments


No Comments To Show