Researchers Conditioned a Group Of Flies To Associate a Particular Odor GMAT Critical Reasoning

Question: Researchers conditioned a group of flies to associate a particular odor with a weak electric shock. Twenty-four and forty-eight hours later the researchers conducted tests on the flies, both individually and in groups, to determine whether the flies retained the conditioning. When tested individually, the flies were significantly less likely to avoid areas marked with the odor. The researchers hypothesized that in the presence of the odor, a fly that retains the conditioned association gives off an alarm signal that arouses the attention of any surrounding flies, retriggering the association in them and thereby causing them to avoid the odor.

The researchers' hypothesis requires which of the following assumptions?

  1. The flies do not give off odors as alarm signals.
  2. Flies that did not avoid the odor when tested individually were not merely following other flies' movements when tested in a group.
  3. Flies that did not avoid the odor when tested individually were less likely than the other flies to avoid the odor when tested in a group.
  4. Prior to their conditioning, the flies would likely have found the odor used in the experiment to be pleasant.
  5. An electric shock was used during the flies' conditioning and during the later tests.

Answer: B
Explanation
:

  1. The flies do not give off odors as alarm signals. The given statement is incorrect because it is possible that flies give the odors as alarm signals. Therefore, this is irrelevant as per the assumption of the researchers.
     
  2. Flies that did not avoid the odor when tested individually were not merely following other flies' movements when tested in a group. The given statement is correct because if the flies did not avoid the odor when tested individually, they were more likely to avoid the odor when in groups. Therefore, the signal does not cause the other flies to react, instead the movement of the triggered flies did.
     
  3. Flies that did not avoid the odor when tested individually were less likely than the other flies to avoid the odor when tested in a group. The given statement is incorrect because this does not tell anything as the statement is trying to compare the flies that did not avoid individually vs other flies in the group that would avoid the smell.
     
  4. Prior to their conditioning, the flies would likely have found the odor used in the experiment to be pleasant. The given statement is incorrect because the kind of odor is not discussed in the given argument. Therefore, the statement is irrelevant.
     
  5. An electric shock was used during the flies' conditioning and during the later tests. The given statement is incorrect because it is not relevant for the hypothesis as the theory basically deals with the signal sent by individual flies.

“Researchers conditioned a group of flies to associate a particular odor”- is a question of critical reasoning in a section of GMAT Verbal Reasoning. It examines the logical reasoning of the candidate in the test. The Critical Reasoning question type is used to measure critical business skills. GMAT Critical Reasoning questions assess a distinct set of qualities associated with logic. The students preparing for the GMAT will experience the argument analysis of Critical Reasoning for the first time to substantiate their logic.

Suggested GMAT Critical Reasoning Questions

Comments


No Comments To Show